Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

When does “only joking” stop being an answer if the child keeps getting upset?

Family category photographFamily

My brother told my six-year-old we'd eaten all the birthday cake while she was outside. She burst into tears. He brought the cake out and said, “See? Only joking.” I laughed at the reveal and helped her blow out the candles.

Yesterday he said her present had been left on the bus, then produced it from behind his chair. This time she asked me quietly whether he'd tell her if something bad had really happened.

My brother is usually generous with her and loves making the children laugh. He thinks a few seconds of disappointment make the happy reveal more fun. I don't think she is enjoying that part, and I wish I hadn't laughed at the first one.

How can I ask him to stop this particular kind of joke without turning the conversation into whether our whole family is allowed to be funny? I also need something better to tell my daughter than that she should know when adults are kidding.

Discussion

5 community replies

“She isn't enjoying being told something she cares about has gone wrong. Please stop those jokes.” You can ask for that specific change without writing a definition of acceptable family humour.

You laughed too, so say that plainly to your daughter. “I laughed when you were upset. I'm sorry. You can ask us whether something is true.” Don't make spotting the trick a skill she has to learn before you will take her reaction seriously.

Your brother already puts effort into making occasions special. Invite him to use a silly surprise that doesn't begin by telling her she has lost something. He can keep the fun of bringing out a cake without making her distress part of the entertainment.

He may argue that she laughed once the present appeared. I'd want to hear what she liked about that moment before deciding the ending makes the whole joke welcome.

Ask her privately and accept a mixed answer: she can like receiving the present and dislike being told it was lost. You don't need her to reject every part of the occasion before asking him to stop the part that upset her.

Join the discussion

More in Family