Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

Dad wants to show the children how he walked on a frozen pond. How do I change our winter outing plan?

Family category photographFamily

We're planning a winter family walk in England. Dad said that if the pond freezes, he'll take the children onto it as he did when he was young. I replied that it would make a lovely photograph before thinking about what I had encouraged.

No one has gone onto ice. London Fire Brigade's water-safety guidance says never to go onto frozen water, including ponds, lakes and canals. I don't want our plan to depend on Dad deciding by appearance that a particular patch looks strong enough.

How do I withdraw my agreement without treating his childhood memories as foolish? I'd like him to share the story with the children, without asking them to recreate it.

Discussion

5 community replies

Speak to Dad before the outing and correct your own enthusiastic answer. The children need a clear plan that doesn't include going onto the ice, rather than two adults debating it beside the pond.

The fire brigade's guidance also says to keep away from the edge near frozen water. Don't replace the promised walk on the pond with a close-up photograph that still brings everyone to a slippery bank.

You can accept that he remembers doing it without accepting the activity for this visit. A familiar story isn't a requirement to repeat every part of it.

Is showing the children the pond essential, or is the important part that they hear about his childhood somewhere he remembers?

Ask him. They can hear the story during another part of the walk or over a meal afterwards. Keeping his place in the family story doesn't require using the pond or its frozen surface as the photograph.

Join the discussion

More in Family