Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

We started giving both children presents on either birthday. How do we stop without blaming the younger one?

Family category photographFamily

When our younger child was small, Grandma brought a little present for him on his sister's birthday. I encouraged it because it made the afternoon easier. We've kept doing it, and he now asks what his present will be whenever a birthday is mentioned.

His sister says she would like one occasion to be about her. Grandma says taking the extra gift away now would be mean. I don't want to tell him he's greedy for expecting a custom we created, but I also don't want the custom to become permanent because changing it will disappoint him.

How do we explain the change before the next birthday and ask the adults to follow the same plan?

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell him the adults started this arrangement and have decided to change it. He isn't misbehaving by remembering what usually happens.

Speak to Grandma before explaining the new plan to the children. If she still arrives with a secret extra present, your explanation will be replaced by an argument at the party.

Your daughter doesn't need to announce that she demanded the change. Hear her wish without making her responsible for defending it to her brother.

Could the younger child have a part in the celebration, such as helping choose a card, without that becoming another disguised present?

Yes, if he wants to help. Invite him into a real part of the day, but don't promise that the job will remove every disappointed feeling. He can take time to get used to the change without his sister having to share her presents to settle it.

Join the discussion

More in Family