Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

We keep asking my son which grandmother he loves best. How do I stop a joke I joined in?

Family category photographFamily

At lunch Mum asked my five-year-old whether he was Nana's boy or Grandma's boy. I joked that it depended who brought the best presents. His other grandmother said he could go home with his favourite, and everyone laughed.

Later he asked whether it was unfair to sit beside Nana when Grandma was there too. I started saying he loved them equally, then realised I was still giving him an answer to perform.

The adults describe this as a game we have always played. How do I tell my son he doesn't have to rank anyone, and ask the family to stop without making him responsible for explaining that the joke has become uncomfortable?

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell him you helped turn the visit into a competition and that he doesn't need to choose a winner. Sitting beside someone at lunch doesn't have to be an announcement about everyone else's place in his life.

Raise it with the grandmothers yourself before the next visit. Be clear that you joined in and are changing your part, rather than saying he complained and leaving them to question him about it.

Retire your presents joke too. You were trying to make the question light, but it gave the adults another way to measure who had earned his preference.

He might enjoy different things with each grandmother. Would insisting he loves them in exactly the same way create a new answer he has to get right?

That is the part to avoid. Let him talk about the people and activities he enjoys without asking for scores or matching declarations. The adults can value their own relationships with him without making his next choice of seat a verdict.

Join the discussion

More in Family