My twelve-year-old wants to stay home alone for an hour. How do I assess this without relying on what I did at her age?
FamilyMy daughter asked whether she could stay home for an hour after school rather than go to Grandma's. I started telling her that I did that at nine. Then she asked what to do if she lost her key, and I realised we hadn't discussed any practical arrangements.
We live in England. GOV.UK says there isn't a fixed legal age for leaving a child alone, but leaving them at risk is an offence. That doesn't answer whether this particular plan is suitable for her.
She likes the idea of some independence and is also unsure about answering the door. Grandma thinks hesitating will make her less confident. I don't want a decision about supervision to become a contest over who had the toughest childhood.
What should we work through before deciding, and how do I leave room for her to change her mind without treating that as failure?