Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My twelve-year-old wants to stay home alone for an hour. How do I assess this without relying on what I did at her age?

Family category photographFamily

My daughter asked whether she could stay home for an hour after school rather than go to Grandma's. I started telling her that I did that at nine. Then she asked what to do if she lost her key, and I realised we hadn't discussed any practical arrangements.

We live in England. GOV.UK says there isn't a fixed legal age for leaving a child alone, but leaving them at risk is an offence. That doesn't answer whether this particular plan is suitable for her.

She likes the idea of some independence and is also unsure about answering the door. Grandma thinks hesitating will make her less confident. I don't want a decision about supervision to become a contest over who had the toughest childhood.

What should we work through before deciding, and how do I leave room for her to change her mind without treating that as failure?

Discussion

5 community replies

Pause the comparison with your childhood and look at the actual plan: the home, the time involved, how she would get in, who is available and what she feels unsure about. A birthday or a confident request doesn't settle all of those questions.

Talk through the situations she has already raised, using appropriate child-safety guidance rather than making up reassuring answers on the spot. Don't leave her alone as the test of whether a plan you haven't finished will work.

Tell Grandma you are deciding what is suitable for this child and this arrangement. She can support the conversation without asking your daughter to demonstrate confidence by dismissing her concerns.

Your daughter should be able to say she isn't comfortable after asking for the freedom. Parents sometimes hear that as changing the deal, especially when another childcare arrangement has already been cancelled.

Keep an alternative in place while you decide what is appropriate. Make clear that raising a concern helps the planning and doesn't make her immature. Adult work or childcare convenience shouldn't require her to claim she feels safe when she doesn't.

Join the discussion

More in Family