Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My son plans to take his partner's surname, and I reacted badly. How do I separate my feelings from his decision?

Family category photographFamily

My son told us he plans to take his partner's surname when they marry. I asked what his grandfather would have thought and said our family name would disappear. He replied that he was telling us his decision, not asking us to vote on how much he values the family.

I had never realised how much I expected him to keep the name. His grandfather has died, and I think I pulled that loss into a conversation that wasn't about him. My future daughter-in-law was sitting there while I made her surname sound like a threat to ours.

I want to apologise before the invitations go out. I don't want to pretend I felt nothing, but I also don't want the apology to become a request for them to reconsider so I can feel better.

What should I say to each of them, and what can I do with the family-history feelings that are mine to handle?

Discussion

5 community replies

Apologise for invoking his grandfather as though that settled the choice. You can say you reacted from an expectation you hadn't examined and that it wasn't fair to make him defend his place in the family.

Include his partner in the repair. She heard her name presented as something that would erase yours. A direct acknowledgement is more useful than asking your son to explain that you didn't mean anything against her.

If you want to preserve family stories or records, choose something you can do yourself. Don't turn a history project into a substitute obligation the couple must accept in exchange for choosing their surname.

Is it still okay to ask why they've chosen this name? Being interested in the decision doesn't necessarily mean trying to reverse it.

Yes, if they want to talk about it and you can listen without requiring a reason you find persuasive. Ask out of interest after you have put right the reaction. If they prefer not to explain further, use the name they have told you they plan to use.

Join the discussion

More in Family