Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My son and Dad share a birthday, but they want different celebrations. How do we stop treating that as disloyalty?

Family category photographFamily

My son shares his birthday with my dad. For years we've had a joint family meal at Dad's favourite restaurant. This year my son wants an afternoon with friends, and Mum says it's sad that he no longer wants to celebrate with Grandad.

I had already told relatives we'd do the usual meal without asking him. He says he still wants to see Grandad; he just doesn't want the whole birthday arranged around the restaurant. I haven't actually asked Dad what matters to him this year.

How do I reopen the plan without making my son defend his affection or assuming Dad must give up everything he enjoys? The shared date has started to feel like an obligation neither of them has been allowed to describe.

Discussion

5 community replies

Separate wanting a different celebration from wanting a different relationship. Your son has said he wants to see Grandad. Don't let the family turn the restaurant into the test of whether that is true.

Tell relatives you announced the usual plan before checking. That removes the need for your son to be the person who publicly cancels everyone's expectations.

Ask your son which parts of his own birthday he wants to choose, and what time together he would welcome. Don't offer him an alternative that has already been negotiated with everyone else.

What does Dad want? The family may be defending a disappointment he hasn't expressed, while leaving his actual preference out of the conversation too.

Ask him privately and without presenting his grandson's wish as a rejection. There may be room for a smaller shared moment and separate celebrations. If their wishes really conflict, discuss that openly rather than assigning one of them the role of selfish birthday guest.

Join the discussion

More in Family