Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My daughter asked if I'd really read her story after I called both endings perfect. How do I encourage her more honestly?

Family category photographFamily

My eleven-year-old asked which ending of her story made more sense. I said they were both perfect while answering a message on my phone. She asked whether I'd actually read them properly. I hadn't.

I often call her stories brilliant because I want to encourage her. This time she asked a specific question, and my praise let me avoid giving it any attention. I don't want to respond by finding faults merely to prove I'm now being honest.

How do I give useful feedback when she asks for it without turning every story she shares into another marked assignment?

Discussion

5 community replies

Apologise for pretending to have given the endings a proper read. Offer a time when you can actually sit with the story, and follow through. The repair starts with your attention rather than a more elaborate compliment.

As a reader, you can say which ending you understood and explain where you became confused. You don't need to rewrite it for her or claim to know what a competition judge or teacher would prefer.

Honest encouragement can include something you specifically enjoyed. Don't manufacture a criticism so that your feedback sounds balanced, and don't use praise as a way to avoid answering the question she asked.

Today she wanted a comparison between two endings. Another time she may just want to show you something finished. A new editing routine could overcorrect if it happens every time she shares her work.

Ask what she wants from that particular read and be honest about the time you have. You can respond warmly to a finished story without offering an assessment, and give focused attention when she requests help. Neither requires pretending you've read closely when you haven't.

Join the discussion

More in Family