Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My cousin wants to use my memory of Grandma as his own in a tribute. How do I change what I offered?

Family category photographFamily

My cousin is struggling to write a tribute to Grandma. I sent him some memories and said he could use whatever helped. In his draft, he's written in the first person about an afternoon I spent baking with her. He wasn't there.

When I pointed that out, he said the story captures how we all felt about her and that I had given him permission. I did offer the material freely. I hadn't imagined hearing him describe an event as his own memory.

I'd like to help him speak without making this a contest over who was closer to Grandma. How do I clarify the difference between sharing a story and pretending to have been there?

Discussion

5 community replies

You can honour the offer you made while clarifying the wording: he can tell the story as something you remember or use it to introduce his own thoughts. He doesn't need to place himself in the kitchen.

Ask what he wants the baking memory to communicate. Perhaps he remembers her generosity in a different setting, or wants to explain what he learned about her from the family. That gives him something true to say rather than just a paragraph to remove.

Keep this between the two of you while the tribute is still a draft. A public correction during the event would shift attention from Grandma to a dispute you already know about.

Some of the most important family stories happened before the speaker was born. He can still feel connected to this one without having witnessed it.

Exactly. 'My cousin remembers an afternoon when...' lets him share that connection honestly. Attribution doesn't require him to rank your grief above his or leave the story out; it simply keeps the event and his reflection on it distinct.

Join the discussion

More in Family