Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My brother wants to attend Mum's funeral, but he and Dad are estranged. How do I avoid staging a reunion?

Family category photographFamily

My brother asked me for the funeral details after several years without contact with Dad. I said he should come and give Dad a hug because it would mean so much. He replied that he wanted to say goodbye to Mum, not promise that everything else was settled.

I am helping arrange the service. Dad knows my brother may attend and says he doesn't want people behaving as though nothing happened. I can understand that. I also don't think I should be negotiating forgiveness through the seating plan.

My brother has asked for practical information, not a speaking role or a family meeting. I want to answer without keeping his attendance secret from the people organising the day, or asking him to perform a reunion so I can feel less anxious about it.

What conversations should I have separately with each of them, and what arrangements can I realistically help with?

Discussion

5 community replies

Correct the condition you attached to coming. You can say you shouldn't have presented a hug as part of attending and ask what practical information he needs. Avoid promising him that Dad will be comfortable or that the day will repair their relationship.

Tell Dad what has actually been proposed: attendance to say goodbye, with no agreed reconciliation. Hear what would make the arrangements manageable for him without offering an apology or embrace on your brother's behalf.

Stop using what Mum would have wanted as the deciding argument between them. You can plan a respectful service without claiming to know that a particular interaction would prove everyone's love for her.

Could some separation during the day help, rather than expecting them to sit together or meet immediately afterwards? It may be useful to discuss that with whoever is coordinating the service.

Yes, ask what practical options are available and communicate them plainly. Separate seating or time with other supportive relatives may help if agreed. Don't turn a discreet arrangement into a staged encounter, or tell either person the other has accepted a conversation they haven't agreed to.

Join the discussion

More in Family