Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My brother offered to drive after the family wine lunch. How do I settle transport before we're at the table?

Family category photographFamily

My brother booked a birthday lunch with a wine pairing and said he'd drive Mum, my children and me home. When I asked whether he was skipping the wine, he said he knew his limits and we could work it out on the day. I replied, “Okay, we'll sort it then.”

The lunch is next weekend. I don't want our transport to depend on an argument at the end about whether someone seems fine. I also don't want to imply that agreeing to lunch means I am keeping count of every glass.

NHTSA recommends planning the ride beforehand and choosing a non-drinking designated driver. I can drive if I don't drink, but we would need another car or another arrangement for everyone.

How do I reopen this clearly after accepting his offer? I want a workable plan, including who pays for any booked transport, rather than a public discussion about whether my brother is a responsible person.

Discussion

5 community replies

Reopen it now: “I left that vague. I need us to agree on a non-drinking driver or other transport before lunch.” You can volunteer to drive within the actual space in your car without promising to solve every seat yourself.

Your brother can choose whether he wants the wine pairing. The decision you need is whether he is taking the role of non-drinking driver. Letting that stay undecided until after lunch creates exactly the negotiation you want to avoid.

Work through Mum's journey as part of the plan, including getting to the lunch and home again. Don't assume she is covered once you and the children have seats. Confirm arrangements with her rather than letting two siblings trade promises about her transport.

What if a taxi can't be found at the end, or someone who promised not to drink changes their mind? A booking helps, but a plan that only works if everything goes perfectly is still rather fragile.

Check availability beforehand and agree what you'll do if the first arrangement falls through, such as waiting for another sober ride or changing the event plan. Someone drinking doesn't become an acceptable driver because the alternative is inconvenient. Keep a way to contact and pay for the agreed backup.

Join the discussion

More in Family