Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My brother booked every popular weekend at Mum's cottage. Is it fair to change a rule he followed?

Family category photographFamily

Mum lets my brother and me use her holiday cottage and told us to put dates on the shared calendar as soon as we knew them. My brother entered six weekends, including both summer bank holidays, on the day she opened it. I looked a week later and found that every date my partner and I had discussed was taken.

I called him selfish. He sent me Mum's message, which really did say first come, first served. He has already arranged leave for two weekends and invited friends for another. I haven't booked anything.

Mum says we should work it out between ourselves, but she also wants to keep several weekends free for her own use. Nobody defined a booking limit or a deadline before unused dates could be taken.

I want a fairer system next year. What would be reasonable to ask for this year without pretending my brother broke a rule that I only dislike now I've lost out?

Discussion

5 community replies

Withdraw the accusation before asking for a concession. He used the calendar as instructed, and some plans are already in motion. You can still say the result showed a problem with the arrangement and ask whether any dates are flexible.

Mum needs to reserve her own dates before the rest is allocated. “Work it out yourselves” won't resolve whether either of you can fill the whole calendar, so ask her what she wants to make available rather than devising a plan for all of it.

For a future year, one round where each person chooses a limited number of dates, followed by a later round for the rest, might suit this family. Ask about priorities before choosing the rule; you may discover that the same two weekends cause most of the conflict.

Do six bookings mean six firm plans? I'd ask him to distinguish the weekends already arranged from placeholders. It seems reasonable to release a speculative booking, even if there was no original deadline for doing so.

It's reasonable to ask, but don't announce a new deadline that cancels his dates automatically. Agree what can change this year and write down any future confirmation rule together. “Could we have this one if it's still tentative?” is more workable than reopening every booking as punishment.

Join the discussion

More in Family