Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My brother asked whether the family can ever take him seriously. How do I stop treating every idea as a joke?

Family category photographFamily

My brother suggested hiring a hall and cooking together for Dad's retirement meal. I made a joke about his last attempt at toast. Everyone laughed, and we moved on. He later said he had actually thought about the idea and was tired of being introduced as the family clown.

He often makes us laugh, and I thought I was joining in. This time he hadn't made a joke. Mum now says we should choose his plan to show we value him, but he says that isn't what he asked for.

I owe him an apology for brushing him off. What would taking his suggestion seriously look like without making the hall the compulsory choice as compensation?

Discussion

5 community replies

The apology can be very specific: he offered an idea, and you used an old mishap to make it a punchline. You don't need to defend the joke by listing the times he has enjoyed being funny.

Give him the discussion he didn't get. What would the hall involve, who would want to cook and what does Dad want from the meal? Assess the proposal by the same questions you would ask about anyone else's.

Mum's proposed repair still makes his role in the family decide the outcome. He is asking to be heard as someone with an idea, not asking for a consolation win.

One missed discussion can be reopened. How would you notice whether the 'family clown' description is affecting other conversations too, without making him catalogue every past slight?

Pay attention to what you actually do next: whether you interrupt a serious point, supply a punchline for him or dismiss an idea before asking about it. You can change those habits without requiring him to prepare a case against every relative.

Join the discussion

More in Family