Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My aunt keeps telling our adopted son how lucky he is. How do I stop gratitude becoming a debt?

Family category photographFamily

Our seven-year-old complained about bedtime at a family visit. My aunt told him he should remember how lucky he was that we adopted him. He went quiet. Later he asked whether other children were allowed to argue with their parents more than he was.

I told him the bedtime rule was the same either way, but I didn't address what she had said. My aunt meant to praise us and says she can't see anything unkind about calling a child lucky. I have accepted that praise in the past, which makes this conversation overdue.

An essay published by Adoption UK questions this language of luck and the idea of who should feel grateful. It gave me a way to think about why her comment bothered me without assuming every adopted person feels the same.

What do I say to my aunt and to my son? I want him to learn ordinary consideration, without hearing that being part of our family depends on never complaining.

Discussion

5 community replies

Return to his actual question: he is allowed to disagree with his parents, and the bedtime decision isn't a judgment on whether he deserves his family. He shouldn't have to earn the right to ordinary childhood complaints by demonstrating enough gratitude.

Speak to your aunt without using his private questions as evidence she must inspect. You can say, “Please don't use his adoption to correct his behaviour or praise us in front of him. Deal with the bedtime issue as you would for any child.”

Acknowledging your own earlier response may help: “I've accepted those compliments, and I've realised I don't want that message attached to his place in the family.” You aren't required to defend every old conversation before changing what you allow now.

Would it help to distinguish thanking someone for a specific kind act from being expected to thank parents for becoming parents? Your aunt may hear the objection as rejecting gratitude altogether.

Yes. He can thank her for a meal or learn to speak considerately, with the same expectations you would otherwise set. The issue is bringing his adoption into a disagreement as though it gives him a special obligation to be easy to parent.

Join the discussion

More in Family