Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

Mum wants the smoke-alarm battery out while she cooks our family dinner. How do I change the plan I agreed to help with?

Family category photographFamily

Mum said her smoke alarm sometimes sounds while she cooks a roast. For our next family dinner, she suggested taking the battery out and putting it back after we'd eaten. I offered to help reach it.

Nothing has been disconnected. I've since read the government fire-safety advice never to disconnect an alarm or remove its batteries because it has gone off by mistake. I need to withdraw my offer and help find a proper answer to the unwanted alarms.

We're also meant to stay overnight. How do I discuss that without issuing a dramatic ultimatum or acting as though the noise she has been dealing with doesn't matter?

Discussion

5 community replies

Correct your offer before dinner: you won't help disable the alarm. You agreed too quickly, and putting the battery back later doesn't make that the plan to keep.

Take the unwanted alarms seriously without guessing at a repair. Follow the manufacturer's instructions and seek appropriate fire-safety advice about the alarm and its location. Don't replace one improvised fix with another.

Offer practical help with the meal while you work out that advice. Mum may hear only that her usual way of getting dinner done has been criticised unless you also acknowledge the problem she was trying to solve.

If there isn't agreement about keeping a working alarm, could you change the overnight arrangement while continuing to help address the issue?

Yes, explain that early and calmly if it becomes necessary. The fire-safety guidance makes working alarms part of protecting the household. Your sleeping plan needn't be a punishment or a demand that Mum admit she was foolish.

Join the discussion

More in Family