Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

Mum wants Dad cropped out of the childhood photo book I'm making. What belongs in the book?

Family category photographFamily

I'm making a small photo book for my ten-year-old about our family's earlier years. One picture shows Mum and Dad at the beach holding me as a toddler. They divorced long ago. Mum saw the draft and asked me to crop Dad out because seeing them together is painful.

I offered to replace it before thinking about what I wanted the book to record. Dad is also my child's grandad, and I don't want to imply he wasn't part of those years. On the other hand, I sent Mum the draft for names and dates, not to make her relive the marriage.

There is no plan to put this picture on display in her home or ask her to celebrate their relationship. This is a book for my child. I could choose a different beach photo, but I'm uncomfortable giving anyone a veto over which parent appears in my childhood.

How do I reconsider my offer without using “it's history” to brush off Mum's feelings?

Discussion

5 community replies

Clarify what you invited her to help with. Checking a date isn't the same as approving the whole book. You can acknowledge that sending the complete draft caught her off guard and offer not to send more images of the marriage.

Keep your reason focused on your relationship with the photograph. “This is a picture I value from my childhood” is easier to understand than announcing yourself the defender of historical truth. You don't need to persuade her to like it.

Ask yourself whether changing this one image would be a choice you genuinely want or the start of erasing Dad throughout. That distinction may help you explain why the quick offer now feels wrong. The answer needn't be that every old photo must be included.

Could you keep the full photograph in your own collection and use a different image in the book? Sometimes the practical compromise is worthwhile without becoming a rule that Mum controls everything.

You could, if it still gives your child the account you want to share. Explain it as your choice about this book, with any future drafts handled differently. If replacing it feels dishonest to you, acknowledge Mum's pain while keeping the picture; don't promise a compromise you already resent.

Join the discussion

More in Family