Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

Mum told my sister we're all against her move abroad, and I stayed silent. How do I correct my part without speaking for everyone?

Family category photographFamily

At dinner my sister described her plan to move abroad. Mum looked at me and said, “We all think you should stay.” I didn't answer. Afterwards my sister texted that she hadn't known I felt that way.

I am worried about being far apart. I haven't decided that moving is a mistake, and I don't think it is a family vote. I let Mum include me because disagreeing at the table felt awkward. That left my sister hearing a position I hadn't actually taken.

How do I explain my own mixed feelings to both of them without replacing Mum's claim with another story about what everyone else really thinks?

Discussion

5 community replies

Reply to your sister directly. Say you stayed silent and allowed the impression that Mum was speaking for you. Then explain your actual view, including the uncertainty, rather than offering enthusiastic approval you don't feel just to compensate.

Tell Mum separately that she must not include you in a statement of agreement without asking. She can express her own wish for your sister to stay; you need to take responsibility for saying what you think when she speaks for you.

You can ask about the plan without making your sister defend her right to decide. Keep curiosity about what she is arranging separate from a demand that she convince the family there will be no regrets.

Are you worried about a specific part of her plan, or mainly sad that you will see her less? Those would be different conversations to have with her.

Separate them before you talk. You can say you will miss her and discuss realistic ways to keep in touch without making staying nearby the required solution. Raise any specific concern as your own question, not as a decision already reached by the whole family.

Join the discussion

More in Family