Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

I volunteered part of my daughter's birthday money for charity. How do I undo that without making generosity sound unimportant?

Family category photographFamily

At a family fundraiser I said my ten-year-old would donate half her birthday money. My aunt praised her generosity before she had answered. In the car she said she had planned to give a little and save the rest for skates.

I thought I was encouraging her to think of others. I actually made a promise using her plans and let the public praise make it harder for her to object.

My mum says withdrawing the pledge would teach her not to keep her word. But the words were mine. I can explain that to the organiser and, if I choose, make a contribution myself. I don't want to imply my daughter owes me the difference later.

What should I say to her and to the adults who heard the announcement, so she can decide what she wants to give without being cast as the child who let everyone down?

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell her the pledge was your decision and she didn't break a promise. Ask what she wants to do now, without setting another donation amount she must choose to prove she cares.

Correct the announcement yourself. “I spoke without checking with her, so that wasn't an agreed pledge” puts the responsibility in the right place. Don't ask her to explain her savings goal to an audience before the correction counts.

You can still talk about why the cause matters and how people help in different ways. Make that a conversation she can take part in, rather than using it as another route back to the amount you announced.

If you cover the difference yourself, be careful about calling it a rescue or saying how much trouble she caused. That could leave the same obligation in place with a different person collecting it.

Agreed. Any contribution you make should be your own choice and something you can manage. Tell her clearly whether you are making one, without treating it as an advance she must repay through money, chores or future donations.

Join the discussion

More in Family