Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

I told both sets of grandparents the same keyboard would be a perfect gift. Now they've both bought it. How do I put this right?

Family category photographFamily

Both sets of grandparents asked what our nine-year-old would like for her birthday. I sent each the same keyboard from her wish list and forgot to say I had also suggested it to the others. They have now both bought it and are excited about giving it to her.

I nearly suggested that one pair choose something else, then realised that sounded as though their offer mattered less. I created the duplication. Neither had any reason to know the gift was already covered.

Our daughter hasn't been told. We don't need two keyboards at home, and I don't know whether either purchase can be returned. I want to check that before promising a quick solution.

How do I tell everyone promptly, take responsibility for any inconvenience and find a practical answer without asking our daughter to choose which grandparents get to give the “main” present?

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell both sets what happened before asking either to change the gift. Be explicit that you sent the same suggestion twice and failed to coordinate it. That avoids a story in which one pair appears to have copied or displaced the other.

Check the actual purchase details and return options with them. Don't promise a refund or a free return without knowing the terms, and don't assume the grandparents should absorb an inconvenience caused by your duplicate suggestion.

Keep your daughter out of deciding which gift giver wins. You can discuss an alternative contribution or present with the adults if they want that. She shouldn't have to perform equal excitement for two identical items to make everyone feel appreciated.

Could one keyboard stay at a grandparent's home if returning it isn't practical? That might still be useful, but only if the family actually wants another place for her to play.

Explore it with the people who would store it and with your daughter when appropriate. Don't assign them equipment or promise regular music visits as a consolation. A useful second location is an option to consider, not a reason to avoid owning the duplication.

Join the discussion

More in Family