Real people. Real opinions.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I said birthdays didn't matter, then treated my partner's plans as a test

Illustration of a small dessert and blank greeting card at a home dinner table for two.Confessions

'I thought you wanted a normal evening,' my partner said. I had just asked why there wasn't even a small surprise.

Two weeks earlier I'd said, very confidently, that birthdays weren't a big deal to me. My partner offered dinner out. I said we should save the fuss and eat at home. What I actually wanted was for them to ignore that answer and invent something lovely anyway.

They bought the dessert I like, made dinner, and gave me a card. I spent the evening waiting for the part that would prove they knew what I really meant. By bedtime I was quiet and prickly, and they asked what they'd done wrong.

I can apologize for the mood. Should I also explain the test I never told them they were taking? It sounds childish written down, but merely saying 'I was tired' would leave them studying the wrong evening for clues.

Discussion

3 community replies

The card, favourite dessert and dinner were already acts of attention. Your private test made them disappear from the score. A useful apology could name those things first, so your partner hears that their effort wasn't inadequate just because it didn't contradict what you requested.

Telling them about the unspoken expectation seems more informative than apologizing only for being quiet. 'I said one thing and hoped you'd do another' explains the mismatch. It doesn't require claiming they should have read your tone better.

What kind of birthday would you actually enjoy: an outing you agree on, a surprise within a plan, or a small gesture at home? 'Make a fuss, but don't ask me to define it' may recreate the test. Giving an honest preference doesn't have to remove every possibility of surprise.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions