Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

I introduced a family swear jar. Can I retire it without teaching my daughter that adults get a different rule?

Family category photographFamily

I put a swear jar on the kitchen shelf after my nine-year-old repeated something I'd said while fixing a drawer. Fifty pence a word, everyone included. She took it seriously.

At Sunday lunch her grandad swore, she pointed to the jar, and he told her not to be cheeky. I paid his fifty pence to move things along. Now she is keeping a notebook because she says she can't trust us to remember.

This was meant to be a light way to notice our language. I've appointed her the household debt collector. My partner thinks we should remove the jar and simply ask everyone to watch what they say. I agree, but I can hear how that sounds after we stopped enjoying being fined.

How do I end my badly designed game while making clear that she wasn't rude for noticing adults breaking the rule I invented?

Discussion

5 community replies

The notebook is a fairly clear review of how the scheme is going. You can say, “I made a game that turned into an argument about collecting money. We're ending it for everyone.” You don't have to defend the jar to be fair about what happened.

Grandad's response still needs addressing. You asked her to notice the words, then an adult criticised her for doing it. Tell her that wasn't fair, and tell him you won't ask her to apologise for following your rule.

Decide what to do with the money already collected rather than quietly pocketing it or leaving a disputed balance. Explain the ending once, including that nobody needs to keep score. The new expectation can be about speaking respectfully without fines.

I wouldn't tell her she is now responsible for politely reminding everyone instead. That could keep the same job under another name, especially while she is already checking the adults' consistency.

Exactly. Adults can correct their own language and each other when needed. She can raise something that bothers her, but she isn't on duty. An apology when you slip would demonstrate more responsibility than asking her to supervise whether every apology happened.

Join the discussion

More in Family