Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

I cancelled both children's cinema trip until someone admitted marking the table. How do I undo that fairly?

Family category photographFamily

There was blue paint on the dining table after my seven-year-old and ten-year-old had been making posters. Both said they hadn't put it there. I said Saturday's cinema trip was off until someone admitted it.

Now the younger one says his sister did it, she says he is only saying that to get the trip back, and I have no better idea what happened. I was annoyed about the table and wanted a quick answer. Instead I've made an accusation the way to rescue everyone's Saturday.

I want to withdraw the shared punishment without announcing that the paint doesn't matter. What can I reasonably do about the damage and the children's accounts when I don't know who is responsible?

Discussion

5 community replies

Withdraw the condition you imposed: the trip shouldn't depend on someone producing the confession you want. Tell them you made that decision while angry and don't have enough information to punish either child for the mark.

The younger child's accusation needs listening to, but it isn't automatically a solved case. Ask what he actually saw without offering a reward for naming his sister. Give her room to answer without turning this into a cross-examination at dinner.

What was the table arrangement before they started? If you supplied paint without agreeing where it could be used, that belongs in the next plan too. A different setup won't establish who made this mark, but it may be more useful than another round of demands.

You can still expect care for shared things. Does cancelling the punishment have to mean dropping the conversation about what happened to the table?

No. Explain the difference between addressing the damage and assigning blame you haven't established. Decide how you'll deal with the table and agree clearer painting arrangements. Don't quietly replace the cinema threat with a new task whose purpose is to make one of them confess.

Join the discussion

More in Family