Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

I bought Dad's present before asking my siblings to share the cost. How do I make their choice real now?

Family category photographFamily

I bought Dad a camera for his birthday and messaged my siblings saying their shares would be due next week. I had chosen it, checked out and signed the card from all of us before either had agreed.

My sister said the amount was more than she could offer. I replied that it would be awkward to take her name off now. That made my purchase her problem. My brother hasn't answered, and I'm starting to see why.

I can cover what I bought, though it means changing my own plans. How do I withdraw the demand without making them feel that accepting their names on the card obliges them to pay later? I still want future group presents to be possible.

Discussion

5 community replies

The first thing to withdraw is the amount you assigned them. Say that you bought it without agreement and will cover it. Their names on a card weren't permission to spend their money.

Speak to your sister about the pressure you added when she told you her limit. She had already given you an answer; she shouldn't have had to reveal more about her finances to make it count.

Let them choose whether to be included in this gift or give something separately. Don't frame either choice as letting Dad down. He can receive a present without being recruited to settle the disagreement.

Would you really be comfortable leaving their names on the card if neither contributes? It's better to decide that honestly than offer it now and resent them at the party.

Decide before you make the offer. You can give the camera yourself, or freely make it a shared gesture without reimbursement. What won't work is keeping an unspoken balance and bringing it back at the next birthday.

Join the discussion

More in Family