Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

I agreed to learn about donating eggs to my sister. How do I stop that being treated as a yes?

Family category photographFamily

My sister asked whether I'd consider being an egg donor for her. I said I would read about it and speak to a clinic. With my agreement, she told Mum we were discussing it. Mum has since said, “At least this part is sorted,” and offered to arrange childcare for my appointments.

Nothing is sorted. I love my sister and want to understand the possibility, but I haven't discussed my suitability or the risks with a clinician, and I don't know how I would feel about the family relationships afterwards.

We're in the UK. HFEA explains the medical process of egg donation and says clinics must offer counselling to help people consider its implications. I want room for those conversations without everyone treating them as steps towards a yes.

How do I correct Mum's account and be honest with my sister about my uncertainty, without asking her to put her own decisions on hold indefinitely?

Discussion

5 community replies

Correct the statement before the childcare arrangements gather momentum. You agreed to explore an option, and haven't agreed to donate. Thank Mum for wanting to help while asking her to stop describing a decision you haven't made.

Speak to the clinic privately about the process, suitability, risks and the pressure you're feeling. The counselling described by HFEA is worth using to explore your actual doubts, including how known donation might affect your family. Don't treat the appointment as a test of whether you love your sister enough.

Your sister needs to hear your position from you. Giving permission to tell Mum that you were talking wasn't permission to turn the conversation into a confirmed treatment plan. You can clarify that without accusing your sister of deliberately misleading anyone.

Uncertainty has a cost for the sister too. Could you agree when you'll next update her, so she isn't left trying to read every family conversation as progress?

An update date could help, as long as it isn't a deadline for consent. Say what information you're seeking and what remains undecided. She can discuss her own options and timing with her clinic without either of you having to pretend your answer is already yes.

Join the discussion

More in Family