Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

Dad bought sugar-free peanut butter for our dog, but the label lists xylitol. How do I explain why we can't use it?

Family category photographFamily

Dad brought a jar of sugar-free peanut butter for our dog because he thought it would be a healthier treat. I thanked him before reading the ingredients. The label lists xylitol, and I put the unopened jar away.

The FDA warns that xylitol is toxic to dogs and can be found in some nut butters. The dog hasn't had any. Dad says he's only trying to spoil him and that I seem to find a problem with every present.

How do I explain this clearly without dismissing the effort he made? I want him to keep asking before offering food, rather than feel that he should quietly try a small amount when I'm not looking.

Discussion

5 community replies

The jar needs to stay away from the dog; a small taste isn't a useful test. Show Dad the ingredient and the warning, while thanking him for checking the label with you now.

'Sugar-free' sounded like a benefit to him. Explain that food chosen for people isn't automatically suitable for a dog, and agree that new treats get checked before being offered.

It sounds as though Dad wanted a small ritual of his own with the dog. Could he have an agreed treat to give, rather than having every visit begin with another rejected purchase?

Choose that together, using your vet's guidance about suitable treats for this dog. Keep the agreement specific rather than approving all versions of a product. He can still be the person who brings a welcome treat without guessing from a human-health label.

Join the discussion

More in Family