Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

Can I ask my sister for lunch just the two of us without making her partner feel excluded?

Family category photographFamily

I asked my sister to have lunch with me and said I missed seeing her on her own. She asked why I didn't want her partner there. They have been together a year, and most of our recent meetings have been big family meals.

I do like him. I also made a tired comment after the last dinner that we'd spent the evening hearing about his new job. She remembers that, understandably, and thinks “just us” is my polite way of saying he talks too much.

I want time to hear about her life and share things I don't bring up around a full table. I don't expect every visit to exclude partners, and I am not arranging a family group that includes everyone except him. This would be one lunch with my sister.

How do I acknowledge the comment I made without giving up on asking for a kind of time together that I miss?

Discussion

5 community replies

Own the comment instead of insisting she invented the concern. “That sounded unkind, and I can see why this invitation brought it back” gives you a better start. Then explain what you would enjoy about seeing her one to one.

An invitation can remain an invitation. She may prefer a different day or not want this lunch right now. You can ask for time with her without making acceptance proof that she hasn't forgotten her family.

Keep inviting her partner to the gatherings where you genuinely want both of them. A single lunch doesn't need to carry your whole assessment of their relationship, but your wider behaviour will make the explanation more credible than a carefully worded defence.

Could “I want to hear about your life” accidentally suggest that her relationship and his job aren't part of it? It might help to be more specific about what you miss.

Yes: say you miss an unhurried conversation between the two of you, including whatever she wants to talk about. You aren't asking her to leave her relationship outside the restaurant. A smaller setting is the request; a ban on certain parts of her life would be something else.

Join the discussion

More in Family