Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

Can I ask my older child not to spoil Santa without making him pretend he still believes?

Family category photographFamily

My thirteen-year-old knows how the presents arrive and has enjoyed helping wrap some for his five-year-old cousin. My sister now wants him to write a letter to Santa and act surprised when the adults discuss the delivery. He says he's happy not to spoil it but doesn't want to perform being little.

I had told my sister we'd all join in, assuming he wouldn't mind. She says the younger child will ask questions if he doesn't do the letter, and that family traditions need everyone to play along.

I like the tradition too. I don't want him teasing his cousin or using what he knows to upset him. But choosing not to make a letter doesn't seem the same as making an announcement at dinner.

What can I reasonably ask of him, and what should I say to my sister about the promise I made on his behalf?

Discussion

5 community replies

He has already offered something useful: not spoiling it. Ask your sister what ordinary activities he can join without pretending to hold a belief. Wrapping, choosing a book or helping set the table could let him participate as an older cousin.

Correct your promise before the gathering. You agreed without asking him, so tell your sister that the letter isn't part of the plan. Don't make him deliver that correction while she explains how disappointed the younger child will be.

Agree with your son that teasing or a dramatic reveal at the table would be unkind. Keep that expectation specific. He doesn't have to become an extra performer in every conversation just because he is expected to treat his cousin considerately.

The younger cousin could still ask him directly whether Santa is real. It would help to discuss that possibility rather than assuming avoiding the letter avoids every awkward moment.

He could refer the question back to the child's parents instead of supplying a speech he doesn't mean. Agree on words he is comfortable with, and let your sister handle the follow-up. An older child can be considerate without being responsible for keeping another household's tradition intact.

Join the discussion

More in Family