Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

We both call ourselves liberal and keep talking past each other

Politics category photographPolitics

My friend and I each used "liberal" as though it explained our position. I meant a concern for civil freedoms. He was talking about fewer restrictions on businesses. A third person thought we were identifying with a particular party.

We hadn't yet discussed the proposal on the table. Somehow we were already debating whether one of us was using our own label incorrectly.

I don't think labels are useless. They can tell people something about the traditions or priorities behind a view. But in that conversation the word seemed to be creating agreement and disagreement before we'd established either.

How do I ask what someone means without turning every political discussion into a dictionary argument? And how do we tell when the disagreement remains substantive after the label is unpacked?

Discussion

5 community replies

Try asking how the label connects to the proposal you're actually discussing. What freedom, restriction, or institution does each person have in mind? That is more likely to reveal the disagreement than deciding who owns the word.

You can state your own usage without declaring it the only possible one. In a public summary, describe the actual position rather than infer a party affiliation from the label.

Don't assume clarifying the word will make you agree. You may discover a real conflict over which freedoms matter, how they interact, or what a particular rule does.

There is a limit to how much definition a casual conversation can carry. One concrete example might tell you more than a long account of everyone's political vocabulary.

Ask about the example already in front of you, then unpack only the part of the label needed to understand the answer. If the disagreement survives, name that disagreement directly. You don't have to finish a history of the word before discussing the proposal.

Join the discussion

More in Politics