We both call ourselves liberal and keep talking past each other
PoliticsMy friend and I each used "liberal" as though it explained our position. I meant a concern for civil freedoms. He was talking about fewer restrictions on businesses. A third person thought we were identifying with a particular party.
We hadn't yet discussed the proposal on the table. Somehow we were already debating whether one of us was using our own label incorrectly.
I don't think labels are useless. They can tell people something about the traditions or priorities behind a view. But in that conversation the word seemed to be creating agreement and disagreement before we'd established either.
How do I ask what someone means without turning every political discussion into a dictionary argument? And how do we tell when the disagreement remains substantive after the label is unpacked?