Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Does a civic project proposal need a polished slide deck to be taken seriously?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our association invited short project ideas describing the aim, likely cost and work involved. One member sent a plain document; another produced an illustrated slide deck. Both address the requested points, but a committee member called the plain proposal 'not ready' because it didn't look like a presentation.

The deck is easier to skim, and I appreciate the effort behind it. Still, we didn't ask everyone to make slides. If information is missing, we should ask for it, but I don't want presentation skills to become an extra selection test after people have submitted.

Would you assess both in their current form, or offer everyone a chance to present? We need to understand what could be delivered, not simply pick the document we'd most like to put on a screen.

Discussion

5 community replies

Assess them against what the invitation requested. If the plain document contains the necessary information, its format alone doesn't show that the project is unready.

A clear presentation has value when it helps the committee understand the plan. Give that benefit its proper scope rather than treating good design as evidence for every practical claim.

If the committee needs a question answered, ask both applicants the relevant questions. An optional presentation can help, but it shouldn't quietly become a new requirement that only one person knew about.

The extra effort could show that the slide-deck author has thought more seriously about delivering the project. I wouldn't want the committee to ignore it.

Nor should it ignore actual preparation. Look for what the extra work demonstrates: clearer tasks, a worked-through cost or an answer to a practical obstacle. Credit those things when present, rather than assuming either polish or plainness tells you how much planning has been done.

Join the discussion

More in Politics