Does a civic project proposal need a polished slide deck to be taken seriously?
PoliticsOur association invited short project ideas describing the aim, likely cost and work involved. One member sent a plain document; another produced an illustrated slide deck. Both address the requested points, but a committee member called the plain proposal 'not ready' because it didn't look like a presentation.
The deck is easier to skim, and I appreciate the effort behind it. Still, we didn't ask everyone to make slides. If information is missing, we should ask for it, but I don't want presentation skills to become an extra selection test after people have submitted.
Would you assess both in their current form, or offer everyone a chance to present? We need to understand what could be delivered, not simply pick the document we'd most like to put on a screen.