Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Are Canadian senators elected in the same way as members of the House of Commons?

Politics category photographPolitics

I'm helping make a comparison chart of parliamentary systems. Beside Canada's Senate, a friend wrote 'elected by voters in each province', assuming it worked like the US Senate. I had left the box blank because I wasn't sure whether the same word meant the same selection process.

The Canadian House of Commons' explanation of Parliament distinguishes the appointed Senate from the elected House of Commons. It says senators are appointed by the Governor General on the Prime Minister's advice.

I'd correct that part of the chart before we debate the merits of the system. Would a short description of the appointment route be enough, or should we also explain the chamber's role? I don't want 'appointed' to become either an accidental claim that senators do nothing or an argument that the arrangement must be good.

Discussion

4 community replies

Correct the selection box first. Sharing a chamber's name with another country doesn't establish that its members are chosen in the same way.

A separate sentence about the Senate's role could help. Keep selection and function in separate boxes so the chart doesn't use one as a judgement about the other.

The comparison would be clearer if each country had the same headings: how members are selected, what the chamber does and what remains outside your summary. You don't need every constitutional detail.

I'd avoid turning a basic chart into a debate about legitimacy. The original question is simply how someone becomes a senator.

Join the discussion

More in Politics