The figures improved after a policy change. Can we say the policy caused the improvement?
PoliticsThe practice chart shows more people using a town walking route after new signs were installed. These are illustrative results in a discussion exercise, not a report of a real programme.
My first caption credits the signs with the increase. Another member asked what else changed during the period and what would have happened without them. We only have the before-and-after comparison on the worksheet.
The government's impact-evaluation guidance distinguishes observing an outcome from attributing it to a policy. I don't want to describe the chart as useless, but I can see that my caption may claim more than it shows.
What can we say now, and what further evidence would help us assess the explanation rather than just the sequence?