Real people. Real opinions.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Funny · Advice & Questions ·

Should I help Grandad remove the spoken punctuation from his messages?

Funny category photographFunny

'Dear grandchildren comma please bring my blue bag question mark love Grandad full stop.'

That was the message. We brought the bag. My cousin read it aloud at lunch like an extremely formal sea captain, and Grandad laughed hardest.

He has started dictating longer family messages. The words 'comma' and 'full stop' sometimes appear in the text. I offered to help him get the punctuation he intended, but he said he liked how commanding the messages sounded. Now he deliberately adds 'new paragraph' before announcing dessert.

Next week I'm putting his reminiscences into a small family booklet. He has sent three pages in the same style. He calls them his letters; I don't know whether he wants the words kept there too. They are funny aloud, but the longer passages are hard to follow on paper.

How do I offer a readable version without deciding for him that his new sea-captain voice is a mistake?

Discussion

3 community replies

Show him one short passage in both forms and ask which he wants printed. You aren't fixing an unknown preference then; you're giving him a visible choice. Keep his original text available so the edited version doesn't quietly replace the letters he sent.

His dessert announcement suggests he has adopted the style deliberately, whatever caused the first message. Helping with dictation and editing the booklet are now separate questions. He can enjoy 'new paragraph' at lunch while choosing ordinary punctuation for longer stories.

Read the difficult passage together and point to the place you lost the sentence. That is more useful than saying all his messages look wrong. He may want to keep an occasional spoken 'full stop' as a joke, or he may decide the page works better without it.

Join the discussion

More in Funny