Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Should candidates be allowed to read notes at our civic forum?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our voluntary civic forum will let each candidate answer the same opening question. One organiser wants a rule banning notes because the audience should hear what candidates know, rather than what they can read. Another says someone may know the subject well and still want figures or a speaking outline in front of them.

I don't want the forum to become a test of memory and delivery. I also don't want a polished statement to take the place of answering the question. Would you allow notes for everyone and use follow-up questions to press unclear answers, or does that lose something useful about hearing an unrehearsed response?

Discussion

5 community replies

Allow the notes. You can listen for whether the answer addresses the question without requiring every number to be recalled from memory.

The organiser's concern is about responsiveness. State the question clearly, keep the same time limit, and ask a focused follow-up when an answer avoids it. A paper ban doesn't itself solve avoidance.

I'd distinguish an opening statement from the later questions. A forum can include both a prepared explanation and a chance to see how the speaker handles a point that needs clarification.

An unrehearsed answer does tell the audience something. I wouldn't want every exchange to be someone reading a page regardless of what was asked.

Neither would I, but the moderator can bring the speaker back to the actual question. Let the audience judge the explanation and the follow-up together. Notes can be available without becoming permission to substitute an unrelated speech.

Join the discussion

More in Politics