Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Should an unanswered neighbourhood return appear as zero in our public table?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our residents' association wants to publish a monthly table of unresolved street-lighting reports sent in by its neighbourhood contacts. In a made-up example to test the layout, North sends an explicit return of zero, East reports two, and South sends no return at all. These are illustrative figures, not local findings.

The table designer has put zero beside both North and South because empty cells look unfinished. The proposed caption then says those two areas reported no unresolved cases. But South hasn't told us whether it has cases; we don't have its return.

I'd prefer 'no return received' for South and a note that this is a list of what our contacts supplied, rather than a complete measure of lighting faults. A committee member thinks highlighting missing returns will look like publicly blaming volunteers, especially when someone may simply have been away.

How would you show the gap clearly without making the table a performance chart for the contacts? Should we publish the available returns with a visible limit, or wait until everyone has answered and risk losing the monthly update altogether?

Discussion

5 community replies

Zero and no return are different answers in your example, so I'd show them differently. A short label can describe the information you have without speculating about why South hasn't replied.

I'd publish the available information with the date and scope beside the table. Waiting might be reasonable for a short, agreed window, but don't let an incomplete return quietly turn into an apparently complete result.

Could the contacts check their own rows before publication? Someone might have sent an update through a different route. That gives them a chance to correct the record without requiring an explanation for every delay.

I'd remove contact names from the public table. Residents need to know which areas have information missing, but I don't see a reason to attach an individual volunteer's name to that gap.

Removing names could help, though in a small association people may still know who covers South. I'd also keep the caption neutral and avoid a ranking of response rates. The gap needs to be visible for readers, not turned into a verdict on the contact.

Join the discussion

More in Politics