Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

Our only child wants a sibling, and relatives say we're denying her a friend. What do we say?

Family category photographFamily

Our nine-year-old said she wished she had a brother or sister. I replied that she had plenty of friends. My sister then said children shouldn't have to grow up without a lifelong companion and offered to “work on us”.

We aren't planning another child. I don't want our daughter to think the decision depends on how persuasively she describes being lonely, or that an aunt can secure a different answer if she asks enough times.

I also brushed past a feeling she was trying to tell me about. She may want more company after school, be curious about a baby or simply wonder what a different family would be like. I haven't asked.

How do I give an honest answer about our plans, hear what the wish means to her and stop the relatives turning it into a campaign?

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell her the grown-ups aren't planning another baby, then make room for how she feels about that. You can acknowledge that your first answer didn't really hear her wish without reopening the family-size decision as something she must persuade you about.

Speak to your sister separately. Ask her not to promise influence or describe another child as a guaranteed friend. Your daughter shouldn't be left waiting for an adult campaign to produce a sibling.

Ask what she imagines enjoying about a brother or sister. That can be a conversation about her actual experience now, rather than immediately offering more activities to make the wish go away.

She might be interested in caring for a baby rather than looking for a playmate her own age. Assuming loneliness could lead the adults to solve a problem she hasn't described.

Exactly. Listen before choosing a response. If she wants more family contact or company, discuss possibilities you can genuinely offer; if she is simply imagining a baby, let her talk about that too. Don't promise a substitute relationship or a caregiving job as the answer.

Join the discussion

More in Family