Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Our note says 'the UN decided'. Should we name the General Assembly?

Politics category photographPolitics

I wrote "the UN decided" in our international-affairs reading notes. Another member asked whether I meant the General Assembly or the Security Council. I had been treating those names as details for a footnote.

We were looking at how resolutions are identified, not trying to assess a particular current dispute. The UN Library's General Assembly guide explains the A/RES/ document pattern and points to the text and voting information.

I want a short account people can follow without turning it into an institutional directory. But leaving out who adopted a text seems a substantial omission if readers are trying to understand what happened.

What should we name in the first sentence, and what belongs in a linked reference, so a precise account doesn't also become an unreadable one?

Discussion

5 community replies

Name the adopting body. The UN Library identifies A/RES/ as the General Assembly resolution pattern. You can write a clear sentence about the General Assembly adopting a text, then link the document instead of making "the UN" carry all the institutional detail.

Keep the resolution number, date, and full text in the reference. The short account should still say what the text calls for, rather than substitute a voting headline for its content.

If you discuss support, use the recorded vote and explain what you're counting. A state's recorded vote isn't a direct statement of what every person in that country thinks.

I'd avoid making the correction sound like "it was only the General Assembly." Naming a body precisely doesn't by itself tell the reader that its action is unimportant.

Right. Identify the body and describe the action, then assess its significance with relevant evidence. Precision should stop readers attributing a decision to the wrong institution; it needn't provide a dismissive verdict in place of the broad label.

Join the discussion

More in Politics