Real people. Real opinions.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

Our daughter translates at every family dinner. How can we let her just join in?

Family category photographFamily

“Tell your dad what Grandma said,” my brother told our ten-year-old daughter, while she was trying to finish a story about school.

My mother mostly speaks Spanish. My partner understands some, but not enough to follow a quick conversation. Our daughter is comfortable in both languages, and everyone has got used to asking her to bridge the gap. At the last dinner she translated a joke, a discussion about my brother changing jobs and three questions about our plans before her own story was forgotten.

On the way home she said, “I don't want to sit in the middle next time.” She isn't refusing to speak Spanish with Grandma. She wants to talk to her instead of passing other people's words across the table.

I speak both languages, as does my brother. We sometimes tell ourselves that asking her is good practice. When I suggested that the adults take turns, he said I was making a simple family favour into a chore. Mum worries that if we stop asking, our daughter will use less Spanish.

I want to keep their conversations going. I also don't want a visit with Grandma to feel like a shift she can't leave.

How do I change the habit at the next dinner without putting my daughter in charge of explaining why it needs to change?

Discussion

3 community replies

Before dinner, tell your brother that you and he will handle translation between the adults. When someone asks your daughter, step in with, “I'll translate that. She was telling us about school.” You don't need her to repeat her complaint at the table. Returning to her interrupted story would make the change visible.

Ask your partner which bits he most wants help following, then arrange for an adult to translate those. He can also ask you directly when he misses something. That gives him a way into the conversation without leaving your daughter responsible for detecting every moment when he's lost.

Your mum could ask your daughter about school, tell her a family story or cook with her in Spanish, if your daughter wants to. Those are conversations they can have with each other. You can invite more of that time without making a claim about how much language practice she needs or turning it into another assignment.

Join the discussion

More in Family