Real people. Real opinions.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

How do we keep part of the holiday at home when both families expect a visit?

Family category photographFamily

“I've already paid for your four seats,” my mum said when I told her we were considering a different holiday plan.

For the last three years, we have opened presents early, driven to her lunch, then crossed town for my partner's family dinner. The driving adds up to about five hours. Our six-year-old asked last year why we had to leave halfway through building his new train track. By the second meal, our nine-year-old was asking to go home.

This year my partner wants us to stay home through lunch and visit one family in the late afternoon, alternating which family gets that visit each year. I like the idea. Mum has already booked a restaurant and paid a $120 deposit for our seats because she assumed we would come as usual. We hadn't discussed changing the plan with her yet.

My partner's parents say dinner is the one time everyone is together. Mum says she would have chosen a smaller table if she'd known. Neither of those points is imaginary, and both of us have been saying “we'll probably do the usual” when asked.

We still have several weeks to settle it. How do we make a clear decision and acknowledge the trouble we've caused without letting every existing tradition become a permanent commitment?

Discussion

3 community replies

Agree on the plan with your partner before talking to either family again. “We're considering” leaves everyone trying to change the outcome. You might choose home until mid-afternoon, one later visit and a separate gathering on another day. Then explain that actual plan, including when you can see the family you won't visit that afternoon.

Your mum acted on a reasonable expectation after you both said “probably the usual.” Acknowledge that directly and ask what the restaurant can still change. If some of the deposit is lost, discuss what contribution you can afford towards it. The booking problem deserves an answer without deciding all future holidays for you.

Alternating can spread disappointment, but it won't make every year's arrangement convenient. Someone may work the other date, and one family may be much farther away. Call it a plan you will review before bookings each year, rather than promising a rotation whose details haven't been tested.

Join the discussion

More in Family