Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My younger child wants the same spending money his sister earns. What is a fair answer?

Family category photographFamily

My fourteen-year-old has saved money from looking after a neighbour's children. When she bought a game, her nine-year-old brother asked us to buy him one too because he can't get the same work. I said I'd think about it. His sister heard that as us paying him for doing nothing while she gives up Saturdays.

He has a point about having fewer ways to earn. She has a point about the time she spent. They each have a small allowance, and we cover the things they need; this is about extra spending, not leaving one child without essentials.

I'm tempted to offer him a list of paid jobs, but I don't want every ordinary household task suddenly needing a price. Nor do I want his sister's purchases to trigger a matching payment.

How can I explain fairness here and decide whether our existing allowance arrangement needs a review, without making the children's finances a running competition?

Discussion

5 community replies

You can answer the request without settling every future allowance: “We aren't buying a matching game because your sister bought one with money she earned.” Then hear his disappointment. A fair reason won't necessarily make the answer enjoyable for him.

Review allowances separately from this purchase. Otherwise he may reasonably learn that the moment to renegotiate is whenever his sister brings something home, and she may feel she has to hide what she earns to avoid an argument.

If you offer extra paid tasks, distinguish those from the contributions everyone already makes to the household. Ask whether there are jobs you actually want done rather than inventing chores purely to produce the same spending total.

I'd avoid praising the older child as more hardworking in the comparison. The younger child has different opportunities; that's true even if buying him the game isn't the answer.

Yes. Recognise her work on its own and acknowledge his limits without ranking their character. You can help him plan towards something within the arrangements you agree. He doesn't need to match her purchases for his own saving to count.

Join the discussion

More in Family