Real people. Real opinions.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

My translation makes a cautious political promise sound definite. Should I share it?

Politics category photographPolitics

I changed "will examine the possibility" to "will do it" because the longer phrase sounded clumsy in the language my aunt reads. When I read the two versions aloud, I could hear the difference.

She had asked for a short translation of a candidate's remarks about reopening a public counter. I speak both languages in everyday life, but I'm not a professional translator. Most of the passage is straightforward. That one phrase is doing a lot of work.

My cousin says people want the point, not every qualification. My aunt has already asked whether she can forward my version to friends who missed the speech. I haven't sent the final text yet.

How much awkwardness should I keep to preserve what was actually promised? If I'm still unsure of the best wording, would it be more useful to send the passage with that uncertainty explained or leave this translation to someone else?

Discussion

3 community replies

Keep the caution even if the sentence takes a few more words. Your translation has changed an intention to examine something into a commitment to do it. That's a substantive change, not just a smoother style. Tell your aunt what you noticed before the version starts travelling beyond her.

Could you put the original phrase next to two possible translations and ask a capable bilingual reader which preserves the level of commitment? They need the surrounding passage too. Another person's opinion may help, but don't turn one quick agreement into a claim that the entire translation has been professionally checked.

Your cousin is right that a translation should be readable. The solution could be a short plain sentence such as "They say they will consider whether to reopen it." If you're confident that captures the original, it avoids the clumsy phrasing without turning consideration into a result.

Join the discussion

More in Politics