Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My sister says the family holiday plan is optional, then gets hurt when I opt out. What should we agree?

Family category photographFamily

My sister made an itinerary for our first holiday together as adult siblings. I thanked her and said I was glad someone was organising us. The plan has breakfast, an outing and dinner together each day, with everything marked optional.

I said I wanted one morning on my own before joining dinner. She asked why I was coming on a family holiday if I didn't want to spend it with them. I called her bossy, which ignored the time she'd spent on the planning I'd welcomed. Now she says she'll cancel the itinerary and we can all fend for ourselves.

We haven't bought activity tickets yet. I want time together and some time alone, but we've apparently attached different promises to the same trip. How do I ask for an arrangement we mean, without expecting her to keep doing the work while treating every suggestion as something to reject?

Discussion

5 community replies

'Optional' doesn't help much if declining is treated as a statement about how you feel about the family. Ask what time together each of you actually expected from the trip, before debating individual breakfasts.

You owe her an apology for 'bossy,' not a promise to attend everything. Thank her for the work and explain the particular morning you want, rather than presenting the whole itinerary as a mistake.

Take responsibility for some of the planning you want to keep. If you suggest one shared dinner, offer to organise it. That gives her a real choice about whether she wants to continue arranging the rest.

How much time together would feel like a family holiday to you? If the only commitment you can name is one dinner, your sister may be hearing a much smaller shared trip than the one she thought you had all agreed to.

Work that out honestly with her. You might want several shared meals and outings as well as a solo morning, but she shouldn't have to infer that from a refusal. Agree the shared parts before any tickets are bought, and make clear that declining the other activities won't need a defence.

Join the discussion

More in Family