Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My sister says my daughter should send her cousin the finished homework. Where does helping family end?

Family category photographFamily

My fourteen-year-old spent an evening working out a set of maths problems. Her cousin, who is in the same class, asked for a photograph of her completed sheet. She offered to explain one problem instead. My sister said a photo would be quicker and that family shouldn't make helping difficult.

I initially told my daughter to be generous. Then she asked why helping meant handing over every answer. I didn't have a good reply.

I don't know whether her cousin wants to copy it or genuinely thinks seeing a worked page will help. I also don't know exactly what collaboration the teacher permits. I don't want to accuse him of cheating, volunteer my daughter as a tutor whenever he is stuck, or make her defend a reasonable limit to her aunt.

How should I put my own response right and discuss a form of help my daughter is actually willing to give?

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell your daughter you answered too quickly and she doesn't have to send the photograph because you told her to be generous. Her offer to explain a problem was already a form of help. Ask what, if anything, she still wants to offer after that exchange.

Speak to your sister yourself. “She isn't sending the completed sheet, and I shouldn't have pressured her” is clearer than asking the two teenagers to settle an adult disagreement about family loyalty.

There may be a real learning need behind the request. That can be taken seriously without making your daughter responsible for fixing it. Your sister can help her son ask the teacher where he got stuck and what support is available.

If the teacher encourages them to work together, a blanket rule against showing any workings might be unnecessarily strict. It seems worth finding out what this assignment is for before deciding which help is inappropriate.

Yes, check the actual instructions rather than inventing a school rule. Even where collaboration is allowed, your daughter can choose whether she wants to share her page or explain a different example. Permission to collaborate doesn't make her completed work a family resource everyone can demand.

Join the discussion

More in Family