Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My sister and I both want to name our babies after Grandpa. How do we stop it becoming a race?

Family category photographFamily

My sister announced that she wants to use Grandpa's first name for her baby. I said that was the name my partner and I had chosen too. She said she had been planning it for years. So had I, but neither of us had mentioned it.

Now our parents are suggesting that whoever has the baby first should use it. I hate that idea. I also realised I was waiting for my sister to offer a different name, as though saying ours aloud made it reserved.

We are close and the children will see each other often. Sharing a name could be confusing, and we each hoped the tribute would feel special. Changing our choice purely to end the disagreement would leave either of us disappointed.

What should we talk through before the family turns a meaningful name into a competition? I want to be honest that I still want to use it without asking my sister to prove she loved Grandpa less.

Discussion

5 community replies

Say that you're considering keeping the name even if she does, rather than waiting for her to surrender it. Then ask how the two of you feel about that possibility. It may be less painful than choosing a winner on a deadline neither person controls.

Different everyday nicknames or using the name in different positions are options if either family actually likes them. Offer them as possibilities, not a clever compromise your sister is expected to accept while you keep your original plan.

Ask your parents to stop treating the birth order as a naming rule. They can care about both grandchildren without refereeing this. The disagreement is already hard enough without relatives announcing who has priority.

What about asking Grandma whether she has a preference about the tribute? If Grandpa's partner is still alive, it might feel odd to discuss the name as though her connection to it doesn't exist.

You can include her if she wants to share memories or feelings, but be clear you aren't asking her to award the name. Making her decide between the sisters could add another hurt. Her connection matters without becoming a vote that settles both families' choices.

Join the discussion

More in Family