Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My parents hear our no-smacking rule as criticism of their parenting. How do I keep the rule clear without debating my whole childhood?

Family category photographFamily

I told Mum we don't use smacking with our four-year-old. She asked whether I thought she had been a bad mother, because she had smacked us. I rushed to reassure her and ended up saying I understood that sometimes children don't listen.

I meant that parenting can be difficult. She heard agreement that there could be exceptions to our rule. There aren't any exceptions we have agreed with her.

The NHS guidance on young children's behaviour advises avoiding smacking and describes other approaches, including consistency and positive attention. My partner and I want the adults caring for our child to follow the approach we have chosen.

How do I correct the impression I gave, hear Mum's feelings without making our child's care depend on reassuring her about the past, and discuss what she should actually do when a visit becomes difficult?

Discussion

5 community replies

Clarify the sentence you regret: understanding that adults get frustrated wasn't permission to smack your child. Tell Mum plainly what the rule is, including that she should call you or ask you to step in rather than improvise an exception.

You can acknowledge that hearing a different choice may feel like criticism without promising that you approve every decision she made. The current care arrangement shouldn't depend on agreeing on one final account of your childhood.

Discuss specific situations she finds hard and the responses you want used. A practical conversation about limits, redirection and getting help is more useful than requiring her to agree with a slogan while leaving the difficult moments undefined.

She may say she can follow the rule while still believing smacking is acceptable. Agreement about a care arrangement doesn't necessarily mean agreement about every belief behind it.

What matters for the arrangement is a clear, credible commitment to follow the rule in practice. Ask questions if the agreement is vague. If she isn't willing to do that, don't organise care that relies on hoping she will change her mind once you leave.

Join the discussion

More in Family