Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My family keeps telling me to stay positive about cancer. How do I ask them to hear me when I'm frightened?

Family category photographFamily

I told my sister I was scared about an upcoming cancer appointment. She said we couldn't have negative thinking in the family and that I needed to keep fighting. I changed the subject and spent the rest of the call making her feel better.

I know she is frightened too. Other relatives have started sending messages about being brave, and I keep replying cheerfully even when I would rather say the day has been hard. I don't want to lose their encouragement. I want room for a truthful answer as well.

Macmillan advises listening to someone's feelings rather than assuring them everything will be fine or urging positivity.

How do I ask for that change without making every relative responsible for knowing exactly what to say? My treatment questions belong with my healthcare team; with my family, I would like to stop performing reassurance.

Discussion

5 community replies

Give your sister a concrete request: “When I say I'm frightened, could you listen for a moment instead of telling me to be positive?” She doesn't need a perfect answer, and you don't need to argue that your fear is sufficiently reasonable.

You can tell relatives which kinds of encouragement you welcome and which words aren't helping. There is no obligation to adopt a fighter identity because somebody offers it lovingly.

Ask for ordinary conversation too, if you want it. The alternative to a cheerful performance isn't a full medical update every time. You may want company, a distraction or a chance to talk honestly; those can be different requests on different days.

What if your sister genuinely can't listen at that moment because she is overwhelmed herself? It would be unfair to assume that caring means always having the capacity for a difficult conversation.

She can say that kindly and suggest another time, while you seek someone else who can listen. It would also help her to find her own support. A limit on today's conversation is different from telling you that fear or sadness is something you must stop expressing.

Join the discussion

More in Family