Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My child celebrates Diwali and Christmas with different grandparents. How do I stop questions about which tradition is “really” hers?

Family category photographFamily

Our eight-year-old was talking about making lanterns for Diwali with one grandmother and decorating a Christmas tree with the other. Mum asked which was the holiday she really celebrated. My daughter asked me afterwards whether one of the visits was just pretending.

These are traditions different parts of our family enjoy and share with her. I don't want to ask her to divide her affection into two equal performances, or choose a side to reassure the adults. I also don't want to answer every question about differences by saying they're all exactly the same.

At the table I said we'd talk about it later, which left the question hanging. Mum says she was only curious about how we explain things at home.

How can I answer my daughter honestly and ask the grandparents to share what their traditions mean to them, without making her the person who has to settle which part of the family counts as her real one?

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with the worry she named: spending time in both traditions doesn't make one set of grandparents pretend family. Explain what your own household does and leave room for questions, rather than asking her to identify the correct side.

Tell Mum how the question landed without claiming to know that she intended a loyalty test. Ask her to talk about what she enjoys and believes, rather than asking your daughter to select the family tradition that is truly hers.

The grandparents can tell their own stories and explain particular activities without ranking the other household. Your daughter can be curious or prefer some activities to others; she doesn't have to demonstrate equal enthusiasm to keep everyone feeling valued.

What if she is asked to join a prayer or another practice she doesn't understand or feel comfortable doing? Enjoying two celebrations doesn't automatically settle every choice about participation.

Ask about the particular activity and what it means in that household, then discuss her questions and comfort. Don't assume attending a celebration requires the same participation in every part. Let the adults explain their own practices instead of asking her to reconcile them at the table.

Join the discussion

More in Family