Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My brother wants to keep some of Mum's ashes. I thought we'd agreed to scatter them all. How do we reopen the plan?

Family category photographFamily

I booked a boat on the Broads for a small gathering to scatter Mum's ashes. My brother had agreed that the river she loved was a good place. He has now said he meant for the ceremony, and wants to keep a portion afterwards.

Mum didn't leave us clear instructions about this. I heard his agreement as a decision about all the ashes and booked before asking. Keeping some feels unfinished to me; scattering everything feels irreversible to him. Neither of those feelings tells us what Mum would have chosen.

The Broads Authority gives local guidance on scattering ashes, including choosing a suitable site and keeping other objects and tributes out of the water. We still need to check the practical arrangements and clarify with the funeral director who can authorise what.

How do we discuss the part we never actually agreed on without treating the boat booking as the deciding vote?

Discussion

5 community replies

Start by acknowledging the gap in the agreement. He agreed to a location; you assumed that also settled how much would be scattered. You don't need to decide that either memory is dishonest to recognise that you hadn't asked the same question.

Ask what keeping a portion would mean to him and explain what feels unfinished to you. Neither of you needs to turn a personal response into a claim that it is the respectful way to grieve.

Before anyone divides or scatters anything, clarify the authority and arrangements with the funeral director and relevant site or boat operator. The linked local guidance doesn't decide a disagreement between relatives or confirm that your particular plan is suitable.

If you cannot agree before the booking, postponing may have a cost. Does that make it reasonable to proceed with a smaller ceremony that leaves the disputed part untouched?

Possibly, if the relevant people actually agree and the arrangement is authorised. Check what can be changed with the operator rather than promising a refund or a particular alternative. The money already committed deserves discussion, but it doesn't supply the missing agreement about Mum's ashes.

Join the discussion

More in Family