Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

My brother repaid the loan, but I still bring it up when we disagree. How do I stop treating help as a lasting obligation?

Family category photographFamily

My brother said he couldn't come to the family weekend I'd organised. I replied that I had managed to be there for him when he needed money. He said, 'I paid you back. What else am I still paying for?'

He repaid the loan in full on the date we agreed. I chose to lend it and never said that he would owe me visits or favours afterwards. At the time I was proud that he trusted me enough to ask.

I was disappointed about the weekend, but I used the loan because it made my complaint harder to refuse. Now he says he won't ask me for help again. An apology seems necessary, and 'you don't owe me anything' will sound empty if I reach for the same example next time. How do I make this right without asking him to reassure me that I'm still a generous sibling?

Discussion

5 community replies

Answer the question he actually asked: the loan is repaid, and he isn't still paying for it through attendance or favours. Acknowledge that you introduced a condition after the agreement had ended.

Keep your disappointment about the weekend out of the apology. If you finish with 'but I just wanted everyone together,' he'll be back in the position of defending his absence before you have withdrawn the unfair comparison.

What would change this is how you respond the next time he says no. Accept that answer without listing what you've done for him. He may need to see that happen before he believes another offer of help comes without an extra obligation.

Helping him may have cost you something emotionally even though the money was repaid. Is there room to acknowledge feeling taken for granted without pretending that feeling disappeared?

There is, but it needs its own honest explanation. If you want more time together or feel that you always initiate contact, describe that pattern and hear his view. The repaid loan can't establish that he owes the particular weekend you chose.

Join the discussion

More in Family