Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Is the European Court of Human Rights part of the European Union?

Politics category photographPolitics

A draft article for our politics group calls a decision from Strasbourg 'an EU court ruling' because it came from the European Court of Human Rights. The editor thinks replacing that phrase would be a distracting technical correction in an article about the decision's political implications.

The Council of Europe's guide to the institutions distinguishes the European Court of Human Rights, which oversees the European Convention on Human Rights, from the Court of Justice of the European Union, which deals with EU law. Calling the Strasbourg court an EU court changes which institution the article says acted.

I'd use its full name on first mention and shorten it afterward. Is that enough for a general political discussion? We aren't assessing an individual's case or trying to summarise the legal effect of a particular judgment.

Discussion

5 community replies

Make the correction. Readers can disagree about a ruling while still being told accurately which court issued it.

The full name on first mention is useful. 'European' by itself doesn't tell the reader that an institution belongs to the EU.

I'd keep the distinction short rather than adding a long account of every European body. One accurate sentence can give the article the foundation its political argument needs.

If the article is mostly about the consequences, could the correction sound like a way of avoiding the substance?

Only if it replaces the substantive discussion. Correct the institution and continue with the argument, supported by evidence about the actual ruling. Accuracy about who acted doesn't settle whether the decision was good, and it doesn't prevent that question being discussed.

Join the discussion

More in Politics