Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

If one person represents two groups, should they get two votes?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our civic forum has delegates from local organisations. One person now represents both a residents’ group and a traders’ group. They asked to cast a vote for each organisation at the next meeting. I initially said that sounded unfair because everyone else would raise only one hand.

Then they asked why either organisation should lose its voice just because the same person was available to attend. Our meeting notes use both “members” and “delegates,” and nobody has yet produced a clear rule saying whether a vote belongs to a person, an organisation or a particular seat.

The next decision could be close, and I disagree with the delegate on the proposal. How can we resolve this without inventing a rule around the result we want? Would asking one organisation to appoint a different delegate solve the representation problem, or just hide the unresolved voting rule?

Discussion

5 community replies

Find the document or decision that established the forum’s voting arrangements. “One person, one vote” may be your preferred design, but don’t present it as an existing rule until you know what was agreed.

The delegate has identified a real design question. A forum of organisations may choose differently from an association of individual members. Decide what the forum is representing before counting hands.

Clarify how a delegate receives authority from each organisation too. Holding two roles isn’t enough information to know whether either vote is meant to express a separate organisation’s decision.

Wouldn’t a replacement delegate settle it quickly? There would be two people and two groups, so nobody could complain about double voting.

It could solve the practical attendance issue if each group appoints someone under the forum’s rules. But first establish whether each organisation is entitled to a vote at all. Otherwise the replacement changes the optics while leaving the same ambiguity in place.

Join the discussion

More in Politics